Opens in a new tab

Donzallaz drops re-election bid after forbidden court romance

Tuesday 17th November 2026 on 05:45 in Switzerland

court ethics, Swiss courts, Yves Donzallaz

Swiss Federal Supreme Court judge Yves Donzallaz has withdrawn his bid for another term after a prohibited relationship with a fellow judge brought his position into question, SRF reports. The case has prompted scrutiny of rules governing relationships in the courts.

All Swiss cantons have rules on conflicts of office involving marriage or family ties. Most also include couples in de facto partnerships. Until 1991, the Federal Supreme Court prohibited relationships between judges and court clerks; many cantons still do so.

The restrictions are intended to prevent concentrations of power and preserve public confidence in impartial rulings. A relationship between judges at the same court can give the impression of bias. Court clerks, meanwhile, report to judges, advise them and draft judgments. A relationship could affect their independent consideration of cases or make them reluctant to disagree.

Rules for court clerks vary because each canton organises its courts and defines clerks’ roles differently.

Most courts respond to relationships only when they become a public issue, SRF says. Donzallaz said the couples usually avoid scrutiny because nobody installs a hidden camera outside their homes. In early April, he found a concealed camera in a hedge at his home, aimed at the entrance. The magazine Weltwoche later reported his relationship with Beatrice van de Graaf, citing witness accounts and images.

Public disclosures may initially appear to benefit people seeking to reopen cases. But because the facts have not changed, they are unlikely to secure more favourable rulings, SRF says. Personal resentment or political motives may instead be at play. Donzallaz accused the Swiss People’s Party of trying to remove him because of his pro-European Union rulings, though that claim cannot be proved.

SRF says the Federal Supreme Court and parliament are divided between Donzallaz’s supporters and opponents, while van de Graaf herself has faced little opposition. She could risk becoming a scapegoat. Donzallaz’s late withdrawal, however, cleared the way for the parliamentary judiciary committee to describe the relationship as “not a very serious breach of official duties” and recommend van de Graaf for re-election. Parliament has yet to decide.

Source 
(via SRF)