Experts question value of ankle monitors for children
Monday 16th November 2026 on 19:01 in
Austria
Vienna youth councillor Bettina Emmerling has proposed electronic ankle monitors for children under 14 who commit offences, but experts have questioned whether the measure would be effective, ORF reports.
Criminologist Veronika Hofinger called the proposal “symbolic politics”, saying children under 14 would remain below the age of criminal responsibility and face no consequences for breaching monitoring conditions. “What would the police do if a child with an ankle monitor did something they were not allowed to do? Nothing would change,” Hofinger told ORF’s Wien heute programme.
Hofinger, who works at the University of Innsbruck, said she did not support lowering the age of criminal responsibility and that other measures should be considered. The NEUSTART association, which supports people placed under electronic monitoring in Austria, also said the proposal was of little practical use at present and would be difficult to implement logistically.
Emmerling, a deputy mayor and youth councillor from the NEOS party, said electronic monitoring could act as a deterrent before children are placed in a “time-out” group home, and could also be used while they are staying there.
Children under 14 cannot be punished in Austria, even when they commit offences. Vienna classifies 61 children as repeat offenders; some commit as many as 15 offences a month. Since July, the city has used a group home where children below the age of criminal responsibility can be held temporarily. The legal basis for the measure is disputed.